February 2023
Problem of the Month

Four Cars
Submitted by K. Sengupta



Four cars travel at constant speed along a road.

Three of them (A, B and C) travel in one direction, and the fourth, D, in the opposite direction.

Car A passes B and C respectively at 9:00h and 10:00h, and crosses car D at 11:00h.

Car D crosses car B and car C respectively at 13:00h and 15:00h.

At what time did car B pass car C?



Solution to the Problem:

Car B passed car C at 11:40h

Consider the speeds as relative to car D (i.e., taking car D to be the "stationary" point of reference).   Let these speeds be S(a), S(b) and S(c).

Car C takes 5 hours from its being with car A to its passing car D, while car A takes only one hour from that event, so S(a) = S(c) * 5

Car B takes 4 hours from its being with car A to its passing car D, while car A takes only two hours,
so S(a) = S(b) * 2

Therefore
Sb = Sc * 5/2

The positions of cars C and B at a given time are given by

P(c)= S(c) * (15 - t) as C meets D at 15 hours.
P(b) = S(b) * (13 - t) as B meets D at 13 hours.

We need the time that P(b) = P(c), so that Pb/Pc = 1, so we can divide one equation by the other:

1 = (5/2) * (13-t)/(15-t)

Solving the above equation, we have:

t = 11 + 2/3

Consequently, car B passed car C at 11+ (2/3*60)h or, 11:40h


Colin Bowey took a more visual approach to the problem:





Here is Ritwik Chaudhuri's solution:





Click here for Dr. Hari Kishan's solution



Correctly solved by:

1. Colin (Yowie) Bowey Beechworth, Victoria, Australia
2. Ritwik Chaudhuri Santiniketan, West Bengal, India
3. Kenneth Bennett Richmond, Virginia
4. Dr. Hari Kishan D.N. College,
Meerut, Uttar Pradesh, India



Send any comments or questions to: David Pleacher